« Are Company Meetings a Waste of Time? | Main | Stuck Happens »
January 26, 2007
Toxic Mentoring
To successfully traverse the world of work, talent and knowledge just aren’t enough. You need people skills and an understanding of the unwritten cultural rules that govern every organization. So mentoring, the pairing of a new (or younger) employee with a more experienced person higher up the corporate ladder, has gained favor as a formal program at many companies. And even informally, it’s wise to seek out a mentor of your own.
Sounds like a win-win, right? The mentor gets the joy of helping others and even favor with his own boss, while the mentee gains institutional knowledge and helps to clear a career path, partially by meeting the right people and getting to know them.
The problem is, we’re talking about people, who don’t always get along and sometimes use work to sabotage each other. According to this BusinessWeek article, the mentor-protégé relationship can often be tainted by jealousy, incompatibility between master and student and even the mentee gunning for the mentor’s job.
This doesn’t mean mentorship programs aren’t valuable -- in fact, they have plenty of benefits. Check out Norma's take as well as Maya’s on people who have positively influenced their careers. It’s just that, like all forms of human interaction, there are chances for peril and disappointment, so proceed with caution.
For more on toxic networking, check out this article.
Share this post: Digg, StumbleUpon, del.icio.us, Facebook, Twitter, etc.
Posted by Christine on January 26, 2007 at 09:20 AM in Career Development | Permalink | Comments (6) | TrackBack (0)
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/8850/7647227
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Toxic Mentoring:
Comments
Interesting piece, and you are definately right, but I'd assume that pairing between mentor and mentee takes place properly by way of character and type fit etc.
I come from a slightly different angle. I'm one of those Non Graduate Entrepreneurs! (statistically speaking there are quite a few of us about) I'm on the lookout for raw passion found in many young people that co ith the same non grad background as I had
Posted by: Sheldon | Jan 29, 2007 8:28:22 PM
I could not agree more about the Toxic Mentor issues
I am in the Corporate World, where I take the initiative on helping New Comers as well as Veterans that are open to receiving new ideas,just happy to have positivity around them. However there is also the usual Jealousy and Sabotage that comes with taking the risk of Mentor Ship, THIS IS COMING FROM A 38YEAR OLD TOP PERFORMER that loves to help and influence others.
Posted by: Ellen Jackson | Jan 30, 2007 10:12:21 PM
I have always found mentorship relationships at work to be positive and enjoyable.
Certainly, I have had a few bad experiences over the years, but the overwhelming majority of these kind of relationships have been beneficial.
I have been both mentor and mentored at various times, because I have always worked in a department where it was essential to work in a hirarchy as a part of a team who must function as a single entity. Learning to stay still and listen to correction, as well as learning how to correct others with kindness and courtesy has really made me grow as a person, as well as an employee.
Posted by: Merry Kanawyer Clingen | Jan 31, 2007 11:37:43 AM
I have been both a mentor and mentee. Based upon a recent experience, I recommend that both parties assess the mentor/mentee relationship regularly. A change in the organizational climate or culture - e.g. in the event of a merger, divestiture, etc., and change that relationship, especially the level of trust that is typically built through candid discussion. You can find yourself in the unfortunate situation of having a mentor or mentee work against you politically within the organization. At the end of the day, human survival instincts will take precedence.
Posted by: KC | Feb 2, 2007 1:27:42 PM
The prospect of a voluntary relationship being toxic is interesting. One can quit. The relationship is not truly mentoring if the mentor is one's employer and/or supervisor and one cannot disregard the input.
Posted by: Robin | Feb 5, 2007 9:32:35 AM
Toxic mentoring can go both ways. As a women in business for 27 years with over 200 employees and managers working for me over that time I faced many situations where I mentored a prospective controller candidate (I, as CFO), or management type. In some cases the women couldn't see past the petty jealousy and scarcity mentality to learn from the experiences. In one case I mention in my book, A Woman's Ladder To Success is Paved with Broken Glass Ceilings, I was mentoring a male controller candidate. Although I never made it personal, never invited him to lunch, never was alone with him behind closed doors, he still perceived an attraction and became obsessed with it. Where I thought I was mentoring, he thought I was interested!
So, the message: BE VERY CAREFUL!
Posted by: ag_ddutton | Feb 7, 2007 10:39:29 PM
